Blog

Holistic API Testing with Playwright: A Legendary Testing Saga

Kiril

blog

Introduction

In this day’s fast-paced development environment, ensuring your web application is bug-free is essential.

While there are various testing strategies, one stands out for its comprehensive approach: Holistic API Testing. In this post, we’ll explore the difference between pure API testing and holistic testing, the benefits of combining End-to-End (E2E) and API tests, and why using the Page Object Model (PoM) is essential for maintaining complex test code.

Whether you’re a novice or a seasoned tester, this guide will help you understand the best practices for using the Playwright Node.js library in your testing strategy.

What is Pure API Testing?

Pure API testing focuses solely on verifying the API endpoints of your application. This method ensures that the backend services are working correctly, independent of the front end.

It’s like checking the plumbing of a house without worrying about the walls and roof.

Benefits:

  • Speed: Tests run faster as they bypass the UI.
  • Stability: Less prone to breaking due to UI changes.
  • Early Bug Detection: Catches issues in the backend before they affect the UI.

However, pure API testing doesn’t cover the user interface or how the end-user interacts with your application. This is where holistic testing comes into play.

import { test, expect } from \'@playwright/test\';
test(\'API test for creating a user\', async ({ request }) => {
  const response = await request.post(\'/api/users\', {
    data: {
      name: \'John Doe\',
      job: \'Software Developer\'
    }
  });
  expect(response.ok()).toBeTruthy();
  const responseBody = await response.json();
  expect(responseBody.name).toBe(\'John Doe\');
  expect(responseBody.job).toBe(\'Software Developer\');
});

Embracing the Holistic Approach

Holistic testing, a hybrid of E2E and API tests, provides a more comprehensive testing strategy.

This approach ensures that both the user interface and backend services are tested, offering a complete picture of your application’s health.

Benefits:

  • Comprehensive Coverage: Tests both the UI and backend, ensuring the entire application works seamlessly.
  • User-Centric: Mimics real user interactions, providing a better user experience.
  • Increased Confidence: Higher test coverage leads to more reliable applications.

Incorporating E2E tests alongside API tests means you can catch bugs that might slip through if you only tested the backend or the UI separately. This combined approach offers a robust safety net for your application.

import { test, expect } from \'@playwright/test\';
test(\'Holistic test for user workflow\', async ({ page, request }) => {
  // API test part
  const response = await request.post(\'/api/users\', {
    data: {
      name: \'Jane Doe\',
      job: \'QA Engineer\'
    }
  });
  expect(response.ok()).toBeTruthy();
  const responseBody = await response.json();
  const userId = responseBody.id;
  // E2E test part
  await page.goto(\'/users\');
  await page.click(`text=${userId}`);
  const userName = await page.textContent(\'.user-name\');
  expect(userName).toBe(\'Jane Doe\');
});

Why Use Playwright for Holistic Testing?

Playwright is a powerful tool for web testing automation, supporting multiple browsers and offering extensive capabilities for both E2E and API testing.

Using Playwright, you can write tests that interact with your application as a user would, while also verifying the backend services.

Key Features:

  • Cross-Browser Testing: Supports Chromium, Firefox, and WebKit.
  • Auto-Wait: Automatically waits for elements to be ready before interacting with them.
  • API Testing Capabilities: Allows for testing API endpoints directly within your E2E tests.

By integrating Playwright into your testing strategy, you leverage a single tool to achieve holistic test coverage, simplifying the testing process and improving efficiency.

import { test, expect } from \'@playwright/test\';
test(\'E2E test for user login\', async ({ page }) => {
  await page.goto(\'/login\');
  await page.fill(\'input[name=\"username\"]\', \'user123\');
  await page.fill(\'input[name=\"password\"]\', \'password\');
  await page.click(\'text=Login\');
  const welcomeMessage = await page.textContent(\'.welcome\');
  expect(welcomeMessage).toContain(\'Welcome, user123\');
});

The Importance of Page Object Model (PoM)

Maintaining test code can become challenging, especially with the complexity of holistic testing. This is where the Page Object Model (PoM) comes in.

PoM is a design pattern that creates an abstraction layer between test scripts and the UI, making the code more readable, reusable, and easier to maintain.

Benefits:

  • Code Reusability: Common functions and elements are defined once and reused across tests.
  • Maintainability: Changes in the UI require updates in one place, reducing maintenance effort.
  • Clarity: Separates the test logic from the details of the UI, making tests easier to understand.

When using holistic testing with Playwright, implementing PoM is essential to keep your test suite manageable and scalable.

// userPage.ts
import { Page } from \'@playwright/test\';
export class UserPage {
  constructor(private page: Page) {}
  async navigate() {
    await this.page.goto(\'/users\');
  }
  async createUser(name: string, job: string) {
    await this.page.click(\'text=Create User\');
    await this.page.fill(\'input[name=\"name\"]\', name);
    await this.page.fill(\'input[name=\"job\"]\', job);
    await this.page.click(\'text=Save\');
  }
  async getUserName(): Promise<string> {
    return await this.page.textContent(\'.user-name\');
  }
}
// userTest.spec.ts
import { test, expect } from \'@playwright/test\';
import { UserPage } from \'./userPage\';
test(\'Create and verify user\', async ({ page }) => {
  const userPage = new UserPage(page);
  await userPage.navigate();
  await userPage.createUser(\'Alice\', \'Developer\');
  const userName = await userPage.getUserName();
  expect(userName).toBe(\'Alice\');
});

Maximizing Test Coverage with Holistic Testing

Holistic testing offers the highest test coverage compared to pure API or pure E2E tests.

By combining both approaches, you ensure that every part of your application, from the user interface to the backend services, is thoroughly tested.

Test Coverage Comparison:

  • Pure API Testing: High backend coverage, low UI coverage.
  • Pure E2E Testing: High UI coverage, lower backend coverage.
  • Holistic Testing: High coverage for both UI and backend.

With holistic testing, you can achieve up to 90-100% test coverage, providing unparalleled confidence in your application’s reliability and performance.

import { test, expect } from \'@playwright/test\';
import { UserPage } from \'./userPage\';
test(\'Holistic testing with maximum coverage\', async ({ page, request }) => {
  // API test part
  const response = await request.post(\'/api/users\', {
    data: {
      name: \'Bob\',
      job: \'Tester\'
    }
  });
  expect(response.ok()).toBeTruthy();
  const responseBody = await response.json();
  const userId = responseBody.id;
  // E2E test part
  const userPage = new UserPage(page);
  await userPage.navigate();
  await page.click(`text=${userId}`);
  const userName = await userPage.getUserName();
  expect(userName).toBe(\'Bob\');
});

Conclusion

Holistic API testing with Playwright offers a powerful and efficient way to ensure your web application is robust and user-friendly.

By integrating both E2E and API tests, and leveraging the Page Object Model, you can achieve comprehensive test coverage and maintain a scalable test suite.

Embrace the holistic approach to elevate your testing strategy and deliver a seamless user experience.

By following this guide, you’re well on your way to mastering holistic API testing.
Happy testing!